Hunter Tierney Apr 15, 2025 13 min read

Nothing Online Feels Real Anymore — And That’s a Problem

Oklahoma's three largest school districts say they have begun to incorporate artificial intelligence programs into their curriculum. They're also having to balance AI's benefits with the risks posed, like with OpenAI's ChatGPT, which can generate entire essays with ease.
Credit: Jeff Lange / USA TODAY NETWORK / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

This is a strange time we’re all living through right now — where you see something online and your first instinct isn’t to believe it, but to ask, "Wait… is that real?" Whether it’s a photo, a video, or even an entire interview, the line between what’s genuine and what’s generated has gotten ridiculously hard to see. 

This isn’t just about a new meme or phony viral videos — it's across the board, from pop culture controversies to news reports about major global events. Nowadays, you could see a full trailer for a sequel to your favorite movie and end up finding out it was just clever AI wizardry.

But this isn’t just a headline-grabber in the tech world. It’s become a big part of how we consume everything online. It doesn’t matter if you’re scrolling through Instagram, reading news on your lunch break, or catching up on group chats — that uneasy feeling sticks around. The central question looming over us is: If we can’t trust what we see, hear, or read, then what’s left? Where do we find our footing as everyday people trying to make sense of the world?

The Rise and Reach of AI-Generated Content

Operations manager Evan Ringle explains the functions of the command center at The Smart Factory in Wichita, Kansas. On the campus of Wichita State University, it has a fully functioning manufacturing production line that combines cutting-edge technologies, including artificial intelligence, machine learning, big data, cloud and edge applications and robotics. It is partnership between Deloitte and companies such as AWS, Dragos, Infor, SAP and Siemens to showcase the power of smart factory technologies.
Credit: Mark Hoffman / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK

AI-generated content isn’t creeping into the online world anymore — it’s flooding it. A recent study from AWS researchers found that more than half of all text online already has some kind of AI fingerprint. 57%, to be exact. Basically, if you’re reading something on the internet, there’s a good chance a human didn’t write it from scratch. It’s happening fast, and for a lot of people, that’s a little unsettling.

We’ve already seen a flurry of blatant examples. From the AI-generated fake job listing that claimed to offer $1,200-a-day remote positions and fooled thousands into giving up their personal info, to the Zelenskyy deepfake that surfaced during the Ukraine conflict, these stories spread like wildfire. 

The reason it’s spreading so fast is because tools like ChatGPT, Midjourney, and Sora aren’t just for tech experts anymore. These tools are as accessible as the social media platforms they're being posted on. Anyone with a decent laptop or even just a smartphone can cook up something that looks legit.

Platforms like TikTok, X (formerly Twitter), and Facebook have become prime real estate for all sorts of synthetic content to go viral. Memes, parodies, and satire all blend together — often intentionally — making it tough to tell if you’re supposed to laugh, get angry, or share it with your friends.

But the real kicker is how quickly this stuff spreads. Before anyone has time to fact-check, it’s out there, weaving its way into debates, comment sections, and group chats. The lines between playful jokes and malicious content get blurry.

When You Don’t Know What to Trust

When you find yourself questioning what’s real every time you glance at a piece of news, it takes a toll on you. We’re at a stage where your first instinct is to doubt, because you know there’s a chance the content could be phony. This isn’t just some minor annoyance — it’s impacting our psychology and the way we connect with each other.

Psychological Impact

Blonde Woman Scrolling on Phone
Credit: Unsplash

A study from Cambridge revealed that 41% of participants fell for vaccine misinformation, and 46% believed the government was messing with the facts. Imagine if nearly half the people watching the evening news thought the anchors were AI-generated and the footage was fake. That kind of doubt doesn’t just stay put — it spreads. Before long, people start second-guessing every video, every article, every conversation they see online. 

Then there’s something called information fatigue. Axios reported that the constant flood of content — both real and artificial — leads to a kind of mental burnout. It’s tough to keep track of which updates are real, and which are artificially generated. Eventually, some people just stop paying attention altogether. They tune out the daily buzz because it’s too exhausting to separate the real from the fake.

The emotional and reputational harm that can be done to people is equally concerning. There have already been cases where AI was used to create fake videos of people seemingly confessing to crimes, making offensive remarks during fake interviews, or appearing in doctored footage at protests they never attended.

Imagine waking up to find a video spreading online of you in a heated argument or caught on security footage doing something illegal — all completely fake. The damage to someone’s reputation, job, or personal relationships could be huge. 

On top of that, deepfake technology was used to pull off a $25 million corporate fraud. A finance worker at a global company got tricked into wiring the money during a video call where he thought he was talking to his real coworkers — but they were all AI-generated deepfakes. The voices, faces, everything looked legit. That’s how real this stuff has gotten.

Social and Cultural Consequences

This erosion of trust goes way beyond just how we personally feel. There’s something called the “liar’s dividend” — it’s when someone can brush off the truth by simply calling it fake. It’s the kind of thing that makes real facts easier to ignore, and it opens the door for anyone to deny anything they don’t like. When that becomes the norm, it gets harder and harder to agree on what’s real at all.

Artistic authenticity is also on the chopping block. AI is composing music, creating paintings, writing novels, and soon, maybe even your favorite artist’s voice or your favorite writer’s signature style. It raises questions about whether musicians, writers, and artists will have to compete against an AI that can mimic their style perfectly. 

Deepfakes, in particular, can destroy reputations at lightning speed. Once you see a believable video of a celebrity or politician doing something outrageous, that image might stick in your mind even if it’s proven fake later. Once people have seen it and shared it, the damage is already done, and it’s incredibly hard to undo.

From Classrooms to Companies: What’s at Stake

Osiel Salazar responds to an artificial intelligence prompt for an assignment during a 10th grade English class at Collegiate High School on Feb. 3, 2025, in Corpus Christi, Texas.
Credit: Angela Piazza/Caller-Times / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

When it comes to money and reputation, AI-generated content can go from playful trickster to full-blown havoc. Market manipulation is already possible if someone churns out convincing fake reports or statements that can tank or boost a company’s stock price. 

Academic integrity is facing its own challenges. If an AI can whip up fake research papers, or if students turn in AI-generated essays, what's to stop every kid from doing it? Universities are starting to implement advanced verification techniques — some people are talking about blockchain-based solutions — to confirm that a piece of work is genuinely authored by a human.

And imagine the cost to businesses and institutions that might have to pay for these verification services. We’re not just talking peanuts here. The financial burden of constantly policing and verifying schoolwork could skyrocket. It’s kind of like a company having to hire outside auditors just to prove their emails are real and their documents weren’t written by AI. The cost and effort to prove you're telling the truth could start adding up fast.

The big question: are we heading toward a future where every piece of content needs some digital seal of authenticity? If so, it’ll be a real scramble to enforce. But right now, universities, journals, companies, and even small businesses are bracing for a new reality: an era where trust needs to be earned and demonstrated in ways we've never had to think about before.

Challenges to Democracy and Civic Stability

Now think about our democratic process, where the stakes are sky high. When the information people rely on to make decisions can’t be trusted, the whole system starts to feel shaky.

AI-generated content poses a serious threat to elections and voter trust. Picture a deepfake of a political candidate caught in a scandalous act or making outrageous statements the day before a major vote. Even if it’s proven fake later, the damage might already be done. A survey indicates 58% of adults worry about AI-generated misinformation affecting elections — a valid concern if you ask me.

It’s not just national or presidential elections at risk. Local ballots, school board positions, and community-level propositions can be swayed by any convincingly faked message. And when those decisions are built on fake or misleading information, it doesn’t just hurt trust — it changes the way communities function.

How Governments Are Trying to Keep Up

Elon Musk, CEO of X and Tesla, arrives before the Inaugural Artificial Intelligence Insight Forum on Dec. 5, 2024.
Credit: Jack Gruber / USA TODAY NETWORK / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Governments around the world are trying to catch up and put rules in place to manage the explosion of AI. We’re seeing everything from executive orders to new bills being drafted, but figuring out how to keep things under control while the tech keeps moving forward is a massive challenge.

Current Regulatory Landscape

The United States made some headlines with Executive Order 14179. Rather than focusing on safety and ethical guidelines like the previous order (EO 14110), this new order aims to remove what it calls 'barriers' to American AI leadership. It prioritizes innovation and global competitiveness, directing top advisors to draft a national AI Action Plan within 180 days. It also called for a review of past policies and a revision of federal guidance to align with this new, more industry-friendly direction.

While it's still early in its implementation, the order signals a move toward fewer restrictions and faster deployment of AI technologies — raising new questions about how to balance innovation with responsibility. 

Over in the European Union, the EU AI Act categorizes certain AI applications as “high-risk.” It’s one of the more structured approaches we’ve seen. High-risk systems — like those used in hiring, healthcare, or law enforcement t —have to meet strict requirements for transparency, safety, and human oversight. Meanwhile, systems with minimal risk, like spam filters, aren’t heavily regulated.

Meanwhile, all over the globe people have been trying to sort out some tricky copyright issues. One big question is who actually owns something made by AI — like a blog post, a song, or even a realistic-looking photo. If no human technically created it, does anyone have the rights? Right now, a lot of it sits in legal limbo, and creators and developers are still trying to figure out where the lines should be drawn.

What’s Missing From the Rulebook

Regulations typically call for things like transparency and explainability. Lawmakers want AI developers to clarify how these algorithms generate their outputs. Bias detection and mitigation is another huge piece. Just as referees in sports need to be unbiased, AI systems should be fair across the board.

Then there’s accountability: if an AI tool spits out something dangerously misleading, who’s on the hook? The developer, the user, or the platform hosting it? It’s a tangled web. And regulating open-source models is another can of worms. You’re basically letting anyone take these powerful AI tools, change how they work, and use them however they want — often without much oversight. There aren’t clear rules, and things can get messy fast.

Global Collaboration 

Keyboard With AI Button on It
Credit: Unsplash

The fight against AI misinformation can’t be handled by any single country, platform, or tech giant alone — it’s like trying to solve a country-wide issue with one local town policy. This is a worldwide problem, and if countries don’t work together on clear, shared rules for how AI is used, we’re going to keep running into the same problems over and over again.

The balance between innovation and regulation is a tightrope walk. We love new tech, but we’ve also got to keep everything fair and safe. Regulations shouldn’t smother creativity; they should guide it. The same goes for AI. We need guidelines that keep things honest without stifling the potential for breakthroughs that can genuinely help society.

So where does that leave us? Maybe we’ll need digital watermarks or authenticity labels, but will that be enforceable worldwide? If half the globe gets on board, and the other half finds workarounds, it’s a never-ending cycle of cat and mouse. Still, the first step is admitting we need a plan, and that plan has to be bigger than any one government or corporation.

Making Sense of the Mess

It might feel like we’re staring at a massive scoreboard of AI-generated content that’s gotten so complex we’re not sure who’s really winning. But step one in any good comeback is recognizing the problem and coming together for a solution. Just like communities come together when something big needs fixing, we need that same kind of collective effort from governments, tech companies, and everyday people to make sure AI is helping more than it's hurting.

We’re in a time where the lines between real and fake have blurred so much that everything can be questioned. The best way to rebuild trust is to face this AI-driven mess directly. That means pushing for real rules with actual consequences, backing smarter tools that can spot fake stuff quickly, and most importantly, making sure people know what to look out for. If we all understand the signs, it gets a little harder for this kind of thing to keep spreading unchecked.

But we can’t just sit on the sidelines waiting for this problem to fix itself. Every fan, every user, every platform has a part to play. Whether you’re fact-checking that wild rumor or verifying a news story about the latest global event, you’re contributing to the pushback against AI misinformation. At the end of the day, it’s about preserving something we all truly care about: our ability to trust what’s in front of us.

Explore by Topic