Hunter Tierney Nov 19, 2026 5 min read

The Lions Need More Than a Next Man Up for Hutchinson

Oct 13, 2024; Arlington, Texas, USA; Detroit Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson (97) lays injured during the second half against the Dallas Cowboys at AT&T Stadium.
Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

Five straight wins, a 7-2 record, and a 25-point blowout in Germany. The Lions should’ve come home feeling pretty damn good about themselves.

Instead, they’re trying to figure out how to finish another season without Aidan Hutchinson.

Detroit’s best pass rusher injured his right knee while landing after a sack celebration against New England on Sunday. By Monday evening, Tom Pelissero reported that additional testing had confirmed a torn ACL, ending Hutchinson’s season. The one bit of good news, relatively speaking, was that the tests didn’t show any other significant damage. The initial concerns about his meniscus weren't an issue.

That’s a brutal turn for a player who’d already been through this once. Two years ago, Hutchinson broke his left leg in Dallas, then battled his way back to post a 14.5-sack season in 2025. He’d already done the miserable rehab-and-comeback thing. Now he has to do it all over again.

The celebration will get replayed endlessly. But once the clip stops running, the Lions are left with the real question: How do they keep this season from slipping away without their best pass rusher?

Six Sacks Doesn’t Tell You Enough

Hutchinson finished with six of Detroit’s 32 sacks. Alim McNeill had 6.5, and D.J. Wonnum had six. On paper, that looks like a defense that can spread the work around.

Then you look at the pressures.

Hutchinson had 50. Wonnum had 22. Same number of sacks, but a very different amount of time spent making quarterbacks uncomfortable.

That’s the part Detroit has to replace. The hurried throw on second down. The quarterback stepping up into McNeill because Hutchinson’s coming around the corner. The protection sliding toward Hutchinson and leaving somebody else with a matchup they can win.

Detroit can spread Hutchinson’s snaps across three guys. They can’t just assume his attention will spread with them.

And when January rolls around, that matters. Good quarterbacks will make a defense pay for giving them even another half-second.

There’s Help This Time

The strongest argument for Detroit holding up is Derrick Moore.

The rookie played 40 snaps against New England and came away with two sacks and four pressures. That came right after another two-sack game in Miami. He’s getting chances, and he’s making the most of them. That’s a lot better than asking a struggling backup to suddenly turn into a starter just because the depth chart says he has to.

Wonnum’s already making plays, and McNeill gives Detroit someone who can mess up a pocket from the middle. There are some useful rotational pieces behind them, too.

But Moore’s job just got a whole lot bigger. He was developing next to one of the best edge rushers in the league. Now Detroit needs him to help carry the position through a playoff push.

That’s a pretty big promotion.

Sheppard’s Got Some Decisions to Make

Detroit Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson (97) gets ready to run out of the tunnel for player introduction before a game against Seattle Seahawks at Ford Field in Detroit on Monday, Sept. 30, 2024.
Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

According to Fantasy Points Data, Detroit's generated pressure on 38.2% of opposing dropbacks while blitzing 28.7% of the time, below the league average of 31.4%. That’s a pretty good way to live: get pressure without constantly sending extra bodies. Hutchinson has been a big reason they’ve been able to do that.

Now, defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard can send more linebackers and safeties. He can use movement and disguised pressures to make protections harder to sort out. He can change the coverage behind all of it, too.

But every option puts a little more pressure on somebody else.

Send another defender, and there’s less help in coverage. Drop seven, and the rushers have to get home before those receivers have time to work open.

Dan Campbell pointed to that relationship after Sunday’s win:

We played some sticky coverage today and bought us a little bit of time.

They’re going to need more of that. And the rush has to return the favor.

The Season’s Still There

The emotional part shouldn’t get buried under pressure rates. Jack Campbell's already on injured reserve after that frightening neck injury, and there’s still no public timetable for his return. Now another defensive captain is out of the lineup. That’s a lot for any locker room to deal with.

Still, I’m not burying a 7-2 team. Detroit's held their last four opponents to 17 points or less, and having Jahmyr Gibbs on the offense can make life a lot easier for a defense that’s running short on bodies.

Tampa Bay's next, then Chicago on Thanksgiving. There’s barely time to catch their breath after Munich, let alone rebuild the defense.

So watch what happens on third-and-long. Can Moore and Wonnum win their matchups while McNeill starts drawing even more attention? Can Detroit get pressure with four?

If they can, the Super Bowl conversation stays alive. But if every stop needs an extra rusher and a cornerback left on an island, January's going to get a whole lot harder.

All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.


Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.

Explore by Topic