Hunter Tierney Nov 22, 2026 6 min read

The Case for Seven More Games of Cade Klubnik

New York Jets quarterback Cade Klubnik (10) throws the ball during an NFL Sunday football game between New York Jets and Buffalo Bills at MetLife Stadium on Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026, in East Rutherford, NJ.

Julian Leshay Guadalupe/NorthJersey.com / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
Julian Leshay Guadalupe / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Watching it through the clips on NFL RedZone, it looked like Cade Klubnik was slingin' it on Sunday.

That was my first impression watching the rookie come out to start the second half against Buffalo. Geno Smith had gotten sandwiched by Terrel Bernard and TJ Parker at the end of the first half, and suddenly a fourth-round pick who'd spent nine-plus weeks holding a clipboard was taking snaps against one of the meanest fronts in the league. He moved the Jets 61 yards on 10 plays, hit Garrett Wilson for 28, picked up a first down with his legs, and looked like a guy who wasn't scared of the moment.

Then I went back and watched every dropback. And the tape tells a much more complicated story.

What the Box Score Says

Klubnik finished 11-of-20 for 137 yards with an interception, plus 26 yards on three scrambles in a 31-12 loss. The situation was messy, too. Smith cleared the concussion protocol, came back for a series, then left again with an ankle injury, so the two of them swapped in and out before Klubnik finished it. That's not exactly a clean audition.

Aaron Glenn didn't bash him after. He called the opening drive "pretty impressive" and said Buffalo's front was about as tough as it gets for a young quarterback. Center Josh Myers said:

For starters, I thought he had just great composure in the huddle. He was very confident, and I thought he ran that whole operation very well, so I was proud of him for that. I thought he did a good job.

All fair. But composure and production aren't the same thing.

What the Tape Says

The first thing that jumped out: Wilson was the first read on nearly every play of that opening drive. That's not a crime by itself. He's your best player, and he finished the day with 7 catches for 106 yards on 14 targets. But Buffalo doubled him a ton, and Klubnik kept going there anyway. Rookies lock onto the guy they trust. That's normal. It's also exactly the kind of thing NFL defenses feast on.

The bigger issue is ball placement. He underthrew a lot of passes, and it's not an arm-strength problem. It's that he just doesn't get enough on it. Even a throwaway that was supposed to sail out of the back of the end zone came up short.

The Fantasy Points Data numbers back that up. Only 35.0% of his throws were charted as accurate — the league average is 58.8%. His completion percentage over expected landed right around zero (-0.1%), so he wasn't getting bailed out, but he wasn't beating tight coverage either.

Here's the part that actually supports the "slingin' it" impression, though. His average depth of target was 11.33 yards. He wasn't dinking and dunking. He was trying to push the ball down the field. The willingness is there. The execution just isn't yet.

There were a few throws where his timing fit the window, where he let it go on rhythm and the ball got there before the defender did. Those are encouraging. There just weren't enough of them.

The Pressure Problem

Buffalo got to him on 46.2% of his dropbacks, way above the 34.8% league average. He was sacked three times on 26 dropbacks, an 11.5% sack rate. Some of that's on a battered Jets line, but not all of it. His average time to throw was 3.09 seconds, and his pressure rate came in 12.8 percentage points higher than expected.

Translation: he was holding the ball and creating some of that heat himself.

His legs were the answer when things broke down. The 8 and 12-yard scrambles on that first drive were legit, and Glenn singled out his movement afterward. I'm buying the legs as a usable weapon under pressure. I'm not convinced the arm is there yet when the pocket gets muddy.

All in, he finished at -0.183 EPA per dropback. That's not good. It's also 26 dropbacks against Buffalo in a game that got away from them.

So What Should the Jets Do?

Garrett Wilson (5) catches a pass for a touchdown as Houston Texans cornerback Kamari Lassiter (4) defends during the second half of an NFL football game Thursday, Oct. 31, 2024, in East Rutherford, N.J. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)

Garrett Wilson (5) catches a pass for a touchdown as Houston Texans cornerback Kamari Lassiter (4) defends.
Garrett Wilson (5) catches a pass for a touchdown as Houston Texans cornerback Kamari Lassiter (4) defends. | AP Photo / Frank Franklin II

Glenn's already made his position pretty clear. Asked Monday if Klubnik could start regardless of Smith's health, he said:

Guys, Geno's our starter.

He also added that he wouldn't be "disrespectful" to Smith by benching him. Smith says he plans to play Sunday against the Chargers, and barring a setback, he will.

I get it. Glenn's got a locker room to hold together, and Smith's been fine. He's thrown for 2,226 yards and 12 touchdowns in a season where very little around him has worked.

But let's be honest about where this team is. The Jets are 2-8. They've lost five straight. They went nine quarters without a touchdown. Smith's 35 and was brought in as a bridge. Everybody's been pointing toward the 2027 quarterback class since April anyway.

So what exactly are they protecting? A shot at 5-12?

The Jets should play Klubnik and focus on '27 anyway. Not because Sunday proved anything. It didn't. If anything, the film made me less confident than the live viewing did. It'll take a lot more than one decent outing to convince me he's a real NFL starter.

That's exactly the point, though. You can't find out from the sideline. Seven more games of Klubnik tells you whether the underthrows are fixable mechanics or a ceiling, whether he learns to work off Wilson when teams take him away, things like that.

Seven more games of Smith tells you what you already know.

All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.


Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.

Explore by Topic