The 49ers Defense Is Giving Their Offense a Lot of Homework
George Pickens spent Sunday making Deommodore Lenoir’s afternoon miserable. He beat him for a 35-yard touchdown, came back with a 39-yarder before halftime, and finished with 11 catches for 145 yards and three scores.
And somehow, the 49ers still won 46-40.
That’s what happens when Christian McCaffrey turns a few short passes into a track meet. It’s a fun way to move to 8-1, but it’s also an easy way to overlook how close San Francisco came to having a real problem.
Fred Warner didn’t overlook it:
The offense, they carried us today.
Nobody in that locker room seemed interested in pretending 40 points was fine just because the offense scored 46.
The question is how much of that afternoon follows the 49ers into January.
Lenoir Had a Rough Day. He Had Company.
There’s some real context behind the Pickens matchup. Lenoir was playing through a foot injury, and Renardo Green was dealing with a bad back that eventually forced him out. Both outside corners missed the week’s full-speed practice work, while nickel back Upton Stout was playing through a shoulder injury. That’s a rough setup against guys like Pickens and CeeDee Lamb.
Dallas deserves credit for attacking it. Pickens used a double move to get behind Lenoir on the first long touchdown. On the second one, he won quickly inside, and Malik Mustapha took a bad pursuit angle that helped turn the catch into another untouched trip to the end zone. That time he had help, and it still couldn't get cleaned it up.
Lenoir took ownership. Good. But making him the whole explanation lets everyone else off the hook a little too easily.
The Pass Rush Needs to Finish Something
San Francisco’s only official sack came when Dak Prescott scrambled out of bounds for no gain late in the fourth quarter. That came after games against Atlanta and Las Vegas where the 49ers didn’t record a sack at all. One sack in three games, with Nick Bosa back for the last two and DeForest Buckner added to the interior, is a pretty rough return on that much talent.
The underlying pressure numbers make it harder to brush off. Fantasy Points Data has San Francisco generating pressure on 29.9 percent of opposing dropbacks, which ranks 30th. Through the first six games, that number was 34.6 percent. Over the last three, it’s dropped to 20.7 percent. The sack rate during that stretch is just 0.8 percent.
That’s a problem bigger than Pickens.
Now, Sunday wasn’t three hours of Prescott standing around untouched. Mykel Williams, Keion White, and Bosa all had five pressures apiece. There were rush wins. There just weren’t nearly enough plays that actually ended the possession.
Kyle Shanahan saw it pretty clearly:
I thought we wore down as the game went.
It's hard to argue with; that defense faded badly in the fourth quarter.
That’s when the game should’ve been getting easier to defend. San Francisco led 38-19 early in the fourth. Dallas had to throw, and the 49ers still gave up three straight touchdown drives. When you know what’s coming, that’s supposed to help.
Coverage and the pass rush feed off each other. Quick separation can beat a perfectly good rush. A clean pocket can eventually beat perfectly good coverage. Warner pointed to the need for tighter coverage and better communication to give the linemen more time. Both groups have work to do.
And Bosa deserves some patience after missing five games with a calf injury. Expecting him to immediately look like he never left is asking a lot. Expecting this front to produce more than one sack in three weeks is pretty reasonable though.
There’s Still a Good Defense in Here Somewhere
I’m not buying that San Francisco’s defense is suddenly terrible.
Through nine games, they're giving up 21.8 points per game. The 49ers rank sixth in total defense and second against the run. Those strengths don’t just disappear because Dallas had a big afternoon.
San Francisco's ninth in overall defensive EPA per play, fifth against designed runs, and 14th against dropbacks. They also rank first in overall explosive-play rate allowed, which is completions of at least 20 yards and runs of at least 10. In other words, this is a defense that’s generally done a good job limiting big plays. They just gave up a few very costly ones Sunday.
The opponent matters, too. Dallas ranks third in passing yards a game through Week 10. Holding Miami to 13 points, Denver to 14 and Washington to 17 was great, but all three teams are in the bottom half of the league in total offense. Dallas put a lot more pressure on the secondary.
Still, San Francisco has already shown they can handle a dangerous offense. They held the Rams to seven points and 290 yards in Australia. That performance against Matthew Stafford counts, even if September feels like six months ago.
The Seattle game is another good reminder to look past the final score. The Seahawks scored 29, but they also got quite a few short fields after 49ers mistakes. Treating every high-scoring game the same would miss a lot of what actually happened.
The recent trend is still worth watching. Opponents averaged 18.6 points over San Francisco’s first five games and 25.8 over the last four. That stretch includes the loss to Atlanta, when four offensive turnovers helped the Falcons score 13 points. The defense didn’t create that entire mess. They also didn’t record a sack while Michael Penix Jr. threw three touchdowns.
Then came five takeaways against the Raiders. This group can still wreck a game. The real question is whether they can consistently get stops when the turnovers don’t come in bunches.
Minnesota Might Make Them Find Out
Sunday night in Mexico City puts that question to the test.
Minnesota gives up 14 points a game and leads the league with 37 sacks. San Francisco averages 31.2 points, so this is a real challenge for a very good offense. It’s also the kind of game where the defense probably shouldn’t plan on giving up another 46.
There’s a funny little wrinkle on the other side, too: Kirk Cousins again. The 49ers picked him off three times when he was with Las Vegas on Nov. 8. Now he’s back in Minnesota, where he just threw two touchdowns in a 30-10 win over Green Bay and found Justin Jefferson nine times for 74 yards. Same quarterback. Different help around him.
To me, the test is pretty simple. Can San Francisco mess with the timing, keep Jefferson from finding easy space, and finish drives once Minnesota gets behind schedule? Can they protect a lead without needing Purdy to answer every single score?
Morris doesn’t need to reinvent the defense. He needs healthier corners and a pass rush that can still get home in the fourth quarter. Those improvements are realistic with this roster.
They’re also necessary. January will eventually throw them a good defense and a possession where the other team knows exactly who they want to attack.
San Francisco got out of Dallas with a win. Next time Pickens — or somebody like him — gets rolling, they need an answer that doesn’t involve handing the problem right back to McCaffrey.
All stats courtesy of Fantasy Points Data.
Want more NFL coverage? Head to Sports Pass for the latest. And for more stories that keep you informed and entertained, YourLifeBuzz has you covered.