Minnesota Election Tie Broken by Drawing Winner's Name From a Bag
A community in Minnesota settled an election in an old-fashioned way when they pulled the winner's name from a bag. Read on for the details about what precipitated this decision.
Minnesota Mayoral Election Decided by Pulling Name Out of a Bag
A suburban city outside of Minneapolis had to resort to pulling a name out of a bag to decide its next mayor. Incumbent Spring Lake Park Mayor Robert Nelson held on to his seat after his name was pulled out of a bag.
City officials and candidates gathered on Monday, November 9, at a special session of a city council meeting to break the tie. The election on November 3 resulted in a tie, with both Nelson and challenger Halyn Roth receiving 1,201 votes, according to Minnesota Public Radio.
Roth took to Instagram the day after the election, saying, “We’ve got a tie, folks. I’m not sure what the next steps are exactly, but stay tuned!” MPR said that city law mandates that in the event of a tie, the winner of a tied election must be determined by drawing lots.
After not being selected in the drawing, Roth confirmed that he was requesting a recount of the ballots cast. The recount is expected to finish on Tuesday, November 17.
Roth shared a video ahead of Monday's drawing, saying that the city's process to break the tie was “not the way I would have preferred to have done it” and that it was “really weird.”
Nelson expressed a similar view of the oddity of the tie-breaking protocol, saying, “Just seems like it’s something from the 1800s, and now we’re in 2026, so I just feel there’s room for improvement, but I have not a clue which way that’d go.” Nelson has served in his current mayoral term since 2019. He had also previously served in the role after being elected in 2006.
About the Drawing Process
Both candidates gathered at Monday's city council meeting to witness the drawing. Nelson and Roth shook hands just before the big moment, with Roth going so far as to offer his competitor good luck.
City administrator Daniel Buchholtz explained to the onlookers that he had folded pieces of paper with each candidate's name and put the papers in identical film canisters. Nelson and Roth were able to observe this process and affirm that it was fair.
Council member Barbara Goodboe-Bisschoff then placed the canisters in one blue grocery bag. Adding some levity to the situation, Nelson joked, "Got a rabbit in there?" Buchholtz replied that he was a city administrator and not a magician.
Goodboe-Bisschoff then picked a canister from the bag and gave it to Buchholtz. A piece of paper with Nelson's name was revealed to the audience and media at the meeting, ending the suspense that had been building for nearly a week.
Buchholtz conceded that it was an unusual way to determine the winner, saying, “I know some people would rather have us do a revote, but doing a revote is really expensive." He told MPR that holding another election would cost the city about $30,000.
Roth told MPR that, “I mean, it was fair as far as it could be; I can’t imagine any other way that we could have done it." He went on to say that “I know there’s a lot of folks who are frustrated by this process, and all I can say is if you want it to change, call your state legislators and ask them to change it.”
Goodboe-Bisschoff also told MPR that she did not know that she was going to be the one to pull the winner out of the bag until she arrived at the council's special session. She explained that Nelson did not want to alert her ahead of time out of fear that she would be too nervous to show up for the meeting.
Curious for more stories that keep you informed and entertained? From the latest headlines to everyday insights, YourLifeBuzz has more to explore. Dive into what's next.